Average car insurance cost in New York

This page states the published average, the source it comes from, the profile it describes, and the state rules that shape every New York quote. It does not state what any driver will pay. No per-carrier price is published here, because no free public source publishes per-carrier premiums, and no "cheapest insurer in New York" claim is made anywhere on this page.

What is the published average?

New York sits 38.4% above the countrywide average expenditure and 33.3% above the countrywide combined premium. Its year-on-year rise was close to the national rise, New York up 13.1% against 11.7% countrywide. For scale, the lowest average expenditure in 2024 was North Dakota at $907.25; New York's figure is more than double it.

Source: NAIC 2024 Auto Insurance Database Average Premium Supplement, September 2026, 2024 data, all insured vehicles, 51 jurisdictions (50 states + District of Columbia). Retrieved 2026-11-06. Current as of September 2026.

What does "average expenditure" mean?

Two different averages appear on this page, and they are not the same number.

Average expenditure is what the average insured vehicle costs to insure in a year. It is the NAIC's headline measure: total premiums earned divided by the number of insured vehicles.

Combined average premium is the sum of the three cover averages (liability, collision and comprehensive) for the average insured vehicle. Countrywide in 2024, the three parts were liability $813.27, collision $516.39 and comprehensive $283.15 per year, summing to the combined $1,612.81.

The NAIC itself warns that state-to-state comparisons should be treated with a high degree of caution, because limits, deductibles, laws and demographics differ between states. New York's figure is not directly comparable to another state's figure as a measure of how expensive one state's insurance "is". The mix of cover drivers buy, the limits they choose and the laws they drive under are all different.

Three consequences follow from the definitions, and they matter more than the headline number:

1. The average mixes every kind of driver and every level of cover. A driver carrying only the state minimum liability will pay less than the average; a driver with full cover on a new car will usually pay more.
2. The average is backward-looking. It describes premiums earned in 2024, published in September 2026. It is not a quote for today, and it does not predict what any carrier will charge next.
3. The average says nothing about any one carrier. Two carriers can charge very different prices for the same driver in the same state, and the NAIC average hides that spread entirely.

What does New York require?

New York's minimum auto liability limits are 25/50/10: $25,000 bodily injury per person, $50,000 bodily injury per accident, and $10,000 property damage. New York is a no-fault state, and personal injury protection of $50,000 per person is required.

The minimums are a legal floor, not a recommendation. The state's own rules page sets out the full position for auto, home and health cover: /auto/new-york-auto-insurance/. A quote that meets only the minimums leaves the driver exposed to costs above those limits after a serious crash, the minimums cap what the policy pays, not what the driver may owe. The required $50,000 of PIP is notably higher than the PIP requirements in most other no-fault states, and it is part of every New York policy by law.

Why does New York sit where it does?

No single factor explains a state average, and this page does not pretend one does. The published figures that can be stated are these: New York ranks 2nd of 51 jurisdictions on average expenditure, 38.4% above the national figure, with a 2024 rise close to the national rise. What moves any driver's price, in New York as elsewhere, is the combination of the cover chosen, the deductible, the vehicle, where it is kept and driven, and the driver's history, and the exact factors a carrier may use are set by the carrier and the state regulator, and vary between them.

What can be said with the published data in hand is where New York stands relative to the rest of the country: second highest in the country on both measures, and the gap to the national figure is wide on both. That is a description of the published average, not an explanation of any individual quote.

What is not published here?

• No per-carrier prices. No free public source publishes what any one carrier charges in New York. Any page that prints a per-carrier New York price without a named source and a date is guessing.
• No "cheapest insurer in New York". A cheapest-insurer claim needs per-carrier prices for a stated driver profile. We do not hold them, so we do not make the claim.
• No quote. This page is a published average with its source beside it. A real price comes only from a carrier or a licensed agent, for a stated driver, vehicle and cover level.
• No rating or review score. We do not score carriers. A public-data ratings page, built from the NAIC complaint index and AM Best financial-strength ratings with its method printed on the page, is planned separately. Nothing is rated here.

How do I use this page?

• Compare the published average with a quote you have received, remembering that the average mixes all cover levels and all drivers. A minimum-liability quote will sit below it; a full-cover quote on a newer car will usually sit above it.
• Read the state rules page for the minimums, the no-fault system and the $50,000 PIP requirement: /auto/new-york-auto-insurance/.
• See every state's published averages side by side on the magnet page: /compare/average-insurance-costs-by-state/.
• Use the comparison tool to work through cover levels and see published averages beside quote-only carrier entries: /compare/auto/.
• Read how every figure on this site is sourced before it is published: /compare/methodology/.